Chicago Steak Company Reviews
Chicago Steak Company is a online steak delievery service that has just about anything a steak-lover could want. From Premium Angus Gold, to USDA Prime and Wagyu Beef, the company has a vast selection of options for every taste. You can even choose if you want your steak dry-aged or wet-aged.
This page was last updated: 2/6/2014
Summary: This is an outstanding service, with a menu full of options, and quality steaks to match.
Our Chicago Steaks Review
- In our experience, we found this company to have a good menu of steaks across the board.
- Free standard three-day shipping on many selections
- Gift club memberships to help return customers save year round
- 100% Satisfaction guarantee and several add-on options for all orders
- Ship anywhere in the USA, but no PO boxes
- Orders are placed online or via the telephone
- A wide range of coupons and special deals are available
- A frequent selection of "specials" and value-added promotions.
- Gift Certificates and Gift Boxes
Prepared Meal, Diet Delivery Services, Gourmet Food, and Premium Steak Companies We Have Tried
Filet Mignon Raw
We started our Chicago Steak Company reviews with the filet mignon that came in the gift box. It was perfectly hand trimmed. We would tend to order larger sizes, but this one was tasted great.
Filet Mignon Cooked
Charred on the outside and deliciously pink in the center, our Filet Mignon was tender and juicy. We had no problem eating both of them as one serving, so we would suggest you get a bunch.
With fast delivery in custom packaging, your steaks are guaranteed on time and there are even options for free delivery. The selection at Chicago Steak Company goes far beyond steaks, as well. From rotisserie roasted beef, ham, and turkey to an assortment of cheesecakes, you can be sure to complete each element of gourmet your home dining experience.
Chicago Steak Company sets itself apart from other frozen food delivery services by providing USDA Prime beef. Hand selected, hand cut, and wet or dry aged, each Chicago Steak Company cut is individually registered. The individual wrapping and registration are designed to insure freshness and high quality. Overall, we found the quality of their beef to be above average.
Chicago Steak Company Review
Top Sirloin Steaks Raw
This is one of our favorite steaks because of its rich flavor and economical price. One of our came split, which almost came apart when it was grilled. It was still quite tasty, and we would order it again.
Top Sirloin Steaks Cooked
These steaks can come in any size and shape, and ours certainly did. We grilled to a perfect 140 degrees and it wasn't as juicy as the Filet Mignon, but it did have a robust flavor.
NY Strip and Ribeye Steaks Raw
The two premium steaks that came with our gift box were the NY Strip and the Ribeye. The Ribeye was a little on the thin side for our liking, but larger sizes are available.
Ribeye Steak Cooked
When these steaks are thin, it can be a challenge not to overcook them. We didn't, but we would have to say this was our least favorite steak that came with our gift box.
NY Strip Steak
The NY Strip was our favorite steak that came with in gift box. It was the perfect size and plenty thick to char the outside and keep the inside nice and pink and juicy. We would order this steak again.
Top Sirloin Filets
These are a great steak to have around for value and flavor. No one cuts them better than Chicago Steak Company. We found these on sale, so load up. Go with the biggest size they have. Yum City on a budget!